Search this site powered by FreeFind

Quick Link

for your convenience!

Human Rights, Youth Voices etc.

click here


 

For Information Concerning the Crisis in Darfur

click here


 

Northern Uganda Crisis

click here


 

 Whistleblowers Need Protection

 

 

Some recent Australian media commentaries

 

For your information - these articles below are just from today's "Weekend Australian" newspaper on the upcoming Games, China, the IOC, the repression in Tibet, etc - also, one of the letters to the editor published today.  Here is the email address for letters to the editor:  letters@theaustralian.com.au

The published letter to the Editor:

Olympics as propaganda

THE Olympic movement, by allocating the games to Beijing, has repeated the mistake of the 1936 Berlin games. The Olympics are being used to propagandise a regime that has an appalling human rights record. We should all decline to watch any of the coverage, thereby denying this dreadful regime the showcase it so desperately seeks. ...... Qld

The articles:

Inflamed by the Olympic torch
Torch's 'journey of harmony' may be torturous for sponsors
Tibetans shot in self-defence: Chinese
Beijing does not have any answers
China hit by a dozen earthquakes

Please see below China's Foreign Correspondent's address - One would understand that any commentary against China would have to be diluted whilst residing within China, but much of his articles of late appear to be just echoing China's state-controlled media reports in regards to China's Government, Tibet, etc.

Rowan Callick
rcallick@gmail.com
Foreign Bureaus
Chaoyang District,
Beijing, China

Top

Inflamed by the Olympic torch

By Glenda Korporaal , The Australian
March 22, 2008

WHEN senior members of the International Olympic Committee sat down with the Beijing Olympics organisers in 2003 to discuss issues that might arise in the months ahead of this year's Games, Tibet was one of a long list of potential controversies.

While the exact nature of the violent anti-government riots in Tibet during the past week may not have been predicted, Olympics organisers have been bracing for the possibility of sensitive issues coming to a head before the August 8 opening ceremony. These include relations with Taiwan and issues of human rights and media freedoms.

"In the lead-up to any Games, we review potential sensitive issues and Tibet was one," says Australia's senior IOC member Kevan Gosper, who is also vice-chairman of the IOC's co-ordination commission for the Games and head of the press commission.

"We have not been taken by surprise," he says. "But the IOC does share the world's desire for the Chinese to bring a peaceful situation in Tibet as soon as possible."

How the Chinese authorities handle the protests in Tibet will be watched closely by the rest of the world in the light of the approaching Olympics that will see more than 23,000 members of the world's media descend on the Chinese capital, along with 15,000 of the world's top athletes and sporting officials and a host of VIPs, including Prime Minister Kevin Rudd.

Used to handling dissent with strong action and strict media controls, the Chinese leaders will be tested during the next few months as they make final preparations for the Games.

The Chinese Government was furious when Hollywood director Steven Spielberg announced recently that he was ending his consultancy on the Games' ceremonies because he believed China was not doing enough to end the civil war in Darfur in Sudan, where it has major investments.

China's anger at the events in Tibet during the past week has been incandescent. But after years of positive press about the Beijing Games, the pressures of dissent are only just beginning to hit the Chinese leaders.

The mild-mannered Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao this week accused the Dalai Lama of instigating riots, as the violence spread from the streets of the capital Lhasa to neighbouring provinces of Sichuan, Qinghai and Gansu.

"The recent riots in Lhasa and other parts of the country were aimed at undermining the upcoming Beijing Olympics," Wen said at the close of the annual National People's Congress meeting this week. Wen said there was "ample fact and plenty of evidence proving that this incident was organised, premeditated, masterminded and incited by the Dalai clique", which he also accused of trying to "stage such appalling incidents in Lhasa and similar incidents in other parts of China and also trying to organise mobs to storm Chinese diplomatic missions overseas".

But the Olympic movement, which is rarely scrutinised except around Games' time, has survived many a controversy or outrage on the way to an opening ceremony.

These have included the killings of Israeli athletes in Munich in 1972, the African boycott of the 1976 Games in Montreal, the Western boycotts of the Moscow Olympics in 1980, the eastern bloc boycotts of the Los Angeles Games in 1984, fears of North Korean-backed sabotage of the 1988 Games in Seoul, concerns about Basque separatist activity in the 1992 Games in Barcelona, a bombing in a park in Atlanta in 1996, the IOC corruption scandal in the lead-up to the Sydney Games and fears of a potential terrorist attack in Athens in 2004.

Staging an Olympic Games, while a huge international accolade, has never come without a price, not only financially but in intense international public scrutiny that becomes more intense as the Olympic flame approaches the cauldron of the main stadium.

But the rise of China on the world stage and the sensitivities over its policies, including Tibet, meant the 2008 Games would be open to hypercharged political issues.

Potential boycotts have been raised - although it is noticeable that the Dalai Lama said this week that he felt the Games should go ahead in the world's most populous country, acknowledging the fierce pride of the Chinese people in being able to host the event.

In Taiwan, the frontrunner in the presidential campaign, Kuomintang leader Ma Ying-jeou, has already used the Games to stir local passions, saying that if he wins today's election, he could bar athletes from the Olympics should the Tibet saga deepen.

"If Chinese authorities continue to crack down on Tibet and the Tibet situation worsens, and if I'm elected as the next president, I would not rule out not sending delegates to Beijing to participate in the 2008 Olympics," he said.

Ma's opponent, Frank Hsieh of the ruling Democrat Progressive Party, also played up the Tibetan issue, saying Taiwan could suffer a similar fate if it were reunited with China.

(Taiwan's continued participation in the Games since China returned to the Olympics in 1984 is an example of the unique, complex diplomacy the IOC has managed to effect to ensure the survival of the modern Olympics.)

The heat will be turned up from Monday when the Olympic flame will be lit in the ancient Greek city of Olympia, at the beginning of a six-week journey through Greece and 19 other countries before it begins its route through China.

The torch will spend the next week in Greece before arriving in Beijing on March 31 and then going on to Almaty in Kazakhstan, Istanbul, St Petersburg, London, Paris, San Francisco, Buenos Aires, Dar es Salaam, Muscat, Islamabad, New Delhi, Bangkok, Kuala Lumpur, Jakarta, Canberra (April 24), Nagano, Seoul, Pyongyang and Ho Chi Minh City before moving on to Hong Kong, Macau and mainland China.

While China has been determined to make this year's Olympic torch relay the biggest and best, the IOC has always been concerned that a long relay outside of China's borders would be open to protesters. While the theme for the torch relay is Light the Passion, Share the Dream, the ignition of the Tibet issue will ensure that there will be passions aplenty along the route, which will give security forces in the cities some giant headaches.

Gosper, who won a silver medal at the 1956 Olympics in Melbourne and competed in the 1960 Games in Rome, says the IOC knows there are risks with a global torch relay. "We have always understood that this torch relay is vulnerable," he says. "We rely on the local authorities in each of the cities through which it passes to ensure the appropriate security."

Gosper is appealing to potential protesters to respect the torch as a sign of international friendship. "This is an Olympic torch. It is not Beijing's torch," he says. "The torch stands for all the Olympic values of harmony and peace and goodwill. We would ask people to respect this and to desist trying to take advantage of the Olympics to promote their own particular agendas or concerns."

As an Olympics approaches, everyone, it seems, becomes an expert, offering their opinions about the host country.

But the IOC survives by focusing on staging a sporting event only, scrupulously avoiding domestic political issues in host countries.

The IOC prides itself on the fact that staging an Olympics can transform the image of a city or a country. The Olympics in Tokyo in 1964 was an important element in Japan's postwar re-emergence; the Seoul Games were a symbol of the stability and rising economy of South Korea; the 2000 Games were a major boost for Australia's international self-confidence and the 2008 Games are a key part of China's rise as a world power.

But by awarding the Games to a city seven years ahead of an opening ceremony, the IOC aims to put in place a foundation to ensure the successful, peaceful staging of the event.

"The public doesn't seem to understand that if you are running the Olympics you do not have the capacity to control the politics of a sovereign country," Gosper says. "There is a false impression in the public at large that a sporting organisation like the IOC has a decree over the political and social agendas of a country. But that is simply not a fact."

That said, once Games' time approaches and the Olympic family comes to town, the situation changes. Beijing organisers, for example, have given their word that the international media will be able to go about their business, reporting the Games with the same freedoms as they would in any other country. This will make life interesting if any groups decide to stage protests in Beijing during the Games.

The assurance by the Chinese allegedly includes free access to the internet, which Chinese authorities regularly monitor and block using sophisticated firewalls.

Such censorship occurred this week when access to internationally broadcast footage of the riots in Tibet was blocked.

As head of the IOC press commission, Gosper will have his work cut out ensuring the Chinese deliver on their promises.

"We are confident the legislative changes in China (regarding the rights of foreign journalists) and the Chinese commitment to their host city agreement will ensure that the internet is free and open to the international press during Games time," he says.

Talk of boycotts is nothing new to the Olympic movement. Gosper and other senior members of the Australian Olympic community still bear the scars of the bitter debate in 1980 when prime minister Malcolm Fraser exerted pressure on the then Australian Olympic Federation to boycott the Moscow Games following the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan. Swimmer Lisa Forrest has published a book about the experience, Boycott: The story behind Australia's controversial involvement in the 1980 Moscow Olympics.

Athletes such as Forrest and distance runner Chris Wardlaw were subject to tremendous pressure to fall in line with Fraser's call to boycott the Games.

Some, such as sprinter Raelene Boyle, buckled and cost themselves potential medals. Despite massive pressure from Fraser, the AOF voted by six to five to defy him and go to the Games, allowing Australia to boast that it has attended every Olympic Games since the revival of the modern Olympics in 1896, a factor it used in selling itself to the IOC in 1993 to win the right to host the 2000 Games.

As Forrest notes in her book, it was not until the 2000 Games in Sydney that many of the wounds from the 1980 vote within elements of the Australian Olympic sporting fraternity began to heal.

Gosper, who voted not to go to Moscow under pressure from Fraser, acknowledged he made the wrong call in his book, An Olympic Life, written with this writer and published in 2000. Fraser himself acknowledged this week that Olympic boycotts did not work and that his attempts to get Australian officials to boycott the Moscow Games were misguided.

Fraser defended himself by saying that his policy was more a matter of falling into line with the policy argued by then US president Jimmy Carter.

Fraser was quoted by The Age as saying, "The individual choices that were made created divisions within sports and between sports. It's not something I would want to see repeated. If I had the chance to argue the policy before, I would have said (to the US), 'We support you in a lot of things, but for heaven's sake don't do this."'

The next few months could prove one of the strongest tests yet of the present generation of Chinese leaders in handling dissent in the modern world at a time when its legendary controls over the media will not work. Staging the Games will change China. Exactly how is still unfolding.

 

Top

Torch's 'journey of harmony' may be
torturous for sponsors

By Rowan Callick, China correspondent, The Australian
March 22, 2008

THE problems between China and its outlying regions, which threaten to cast a shadow over the Beijing Olympic Games, have been highlighted by the recent incidents in Xinjiang and Tibet - and these incidents may not be the last.

Among the most anxious observers of these events are the Olympic corporate sponsors.

First, authorities in Xinjiang claimed that a murky "plot" destroyed by a police raid in the capital, Urumqi, then a foiled attempt to ignite fuel on a plane, were targeted at the Olympics.

Xinjiang is the northwestern region where the indigenous Muslim Turkic Uighurs have become a minority following decades of government promotion of Han Chinese migration.

Then came the explosion in Tibet, which has overflowed to the ethnic Tibetan areas of neighbouring regions, where Han migration has also been resented.

Following the Cultural Revolution and Mao Zedong's death, the Communist Party has largely pursued nationalism in place of the now almost evaporated belief in Marxism or Maoism.

But this development has only served to make some of China's "minorities" feel more marginalised, because of the difficulty that the state has in tolerating substantial differences in political, religious, cultural, and economic ways of life.

It is within this context that the Olympic Torch Relay is due to set off on Monday, its route set towards Tibet, where the torch will be taken up Mount Everest.

The theme of the relay is "Journey of Harmony". It would be a miracle if this were to become its dominant image, given the deepening tensions.

The chief sponsors of the relay are Coca-Cola, South Korea's Samsung, and China's Lenovo.

Hong Kong-based Australian media adviser Damien Ryan is already working with Olympic sponsors on addressing sensitive issues in the Olympic year.

Such issues, he says, include:

* China's response to Tibetan protests, and views on autonomy in Tibet, Xinjiang and Taiwan.

* China's links to Sudan and Burma.

* China's record on pollution, human rights, trade imbalances, an artificially weak currency, and the safety of its products.

These issues would all gain prominence as the opening ceremony approaches, he said. "Sponsors see their involvement in the Olympics as vital, given the growing revenue contribution from China and the sheer potential of the country's 1.3 billion consumers."

He added: "Athletes and Chinese officials will also be probed by the media like never before, on a horde of sensitive issues. A simple 'no comment' or 'politics and sport don't mix' may no longer be acceptable."

What's more, Chinese people are fast losing patience with protesting Tibetans, Uighurs and others. And they are being given space online to vent their spleen.

Recent postings on the China News Service website include: "The Government shouldn't be too tolerant, otherwise it lets the people down, and helps to increase the mob's morale."

Another says: "Equality between the races doesn't mean indulgence. The Government pays wages to the monks, who have nothing to do every day, is that really respecting Tibetan culture?"

 

Top

Tibetans shot in self-defence: Chinese

By Rowan Callick, China correspondent, The Australian
March 22, 2008

THE Chinese Government has admitted through its state media that security forces shot at Tibetan protesters, but said the police had shot four people in Sichuan in "self-defence".

The Chinese statement came as the Speaker of the US House of Representatives, Democrat Nancy Pelosi, arrived yesterday for talks with the Dalai Lama at the headquarters of the Tibetan government in exile in the Indian hill town of Dharamsala.

Ms Pelosi has been a consistent critic of China's human rights record, and five months ago presented the Congressional Gold Medal, the US legislature's highest civilian honour, to the Dalai Lama in Washington, a move that enraged Beijing.

After meeting the Dalai Lama, Ms Pelosi said the free world will have lost its moral authority to speak about human rights if it did not speak up against Chinese oppression in Tibet.

"The situation in Tibet is a challenge to the conscience of the world," Ms Pelosi told a gathering of Tibetans.

"If freedom-loving people throughout the world do not speak out against Chinese oppression and China and Tibet, we have lost all moral authority to speak on behalf of human rights anywhere in the world."

Free Tibet activists have claimed that between eight and 30 people were killed during violent demonstrations in Lhasa eight days ago.

The Chinese authorities said 13 "innocent civilians" - Han Chinese - were killed by Tibetans during the riots.

Beijing has conceded that the protests have spread to areas of Sichuan and Gansu provinces where Tibetan live.

China says 24 people have been arrested in Lhasa, and that 170 of the protesters there have surrendered to authorities.

The number of Tibetans believed to be in custody in the whole region is now believed to exceed 1000.

A BBC journalist in western China counted convoys of more than 400 military vehicles heading towards Tibet, encompassing an estimated 12,000 extra troops heading into the heavily militarised region.

In Jianzha county in Qinghai province, where the exiled Dalai Lama was born, students at the Tibetan Nationalities Middle School were reported to have pulled down the Chinese flag and replaced it with the banned Tibetan snow lion standard, shouting: "Long live the Dalai Lama" before police moved in.

Tibetans who work in government offices are now required to vilify the Dalai Lama.

China says 13 people were killed in the violence and three rioters died, while 325 were wounded. The Dalai Lama's government-in-exile puts the toll as high as 99.

Threats of boycotts of the Olympic Games, or of the opening ceremony, appear to be fading as a tense form of order is restored to China's restive west.

But the torch relay through the region is likely to reawaken hostilities when it arrives, probably in May.

US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said after speaking with Chinese Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi by phone on Thursday that the US had again called for China to exercise restraint. She pressed Beijing to talk to the Dalai Lama.

Beijing and the Dalai Lama have repeated for several years that they are willing to engage in direct talks, but six rounds of preliminary negotiations between representatives have achieved little.

China insists that the Dalai Lama must renounce independence, the Dalai Lama repeats his denials of support for independence, and the two have remained in practice poles apart, despite appearing to be singing from the same songsheet.

The Dalai Lama said: "I am always ready to meet our Chinese leaders, particularly (President) Hu Jintao."

But Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao on Tuesday accused the Dalai Lama of masterminding the latest violence and the latter has come under fire from radical Tibetan students in exile for failing to provide sufficient backing for the protesters.

China has expressed concern that British Prime Minister Gordon Brown plans to meet theDalai Lama when he visits London in May.

China's Foreign Ministry spokesman Qin Gang said: "The Dalai is a political refugee engaged in activities of splitting China under the camouflage of religion. You have seen the relevant videos and pictures on the television.

"Is it a peaceful demonstration or violent crime? So many things happened simultaneously.

"Do you still believe this is a coincidence?"

 

Top

Beijing does not have any answers

By Rowan Callick, China correspondent, The Australian
March 19, 2008

THE Chinese Government is struggling to respond to the Tibetans' rejection of its strategy for their future. And it appears to have no convincing Plan B.

Beijing will be damned by the rest of the world if it launches a fierce crackdown on Tibet, and damned by some of its own citizens if it doesn't, especially since the media has been encouraged to present the events as senseless brutality by the Tibetans against innocent Han Chinese.

The Government could wait until it is confident its media wall around Tibet will hold before acting harshly. And for its domestic audience, it could talk tough while actually adopting a more restrained approach.

But realistically, neither option will work.

China's Great Firewall has held firm so far, effectively filtering out all Tibet information or opinion except that provided by official channels, especially the Xinhua news agency. But news, if distorted because of the bans on reporting, will inevitably leak out - both to the outside world and to the domestic audience.

So a consistent workable strategy is required. Quickly.

The Olympic torch relay starts in a fortnight, and will, distressingly, soon wind its way to Tibet. The Games themselves are less than five months away.

Even sooner, the 23 million people of Taiwan vote for a new president on Saturday. This for China is the pearl beyond price. And it has pinned its hopes on Ma Ying-jeou, the smooth and attractive leader of the Kuomintang (Nationalists) regaining power from the independence-minded Democratic Progressive Party.

DPP candidate Frank Hsieh said yesterday: "We would end up like Tibet if we do not protect Taiwan," adding that Mr Ma - who aims to negotiate a common market with China if he wins - would not protect Taiwan adequately. Mr Hsieh has trailed in all the opinion polls, but Taiwan's voters can be fickle, and he clearly expects to pick up a few points because of Tibet.

Tackling the Tibetan problem is especially difficult for Beijing because only half the 5.4 million ethnic Tibetans in China live in the Tibet region.

The rest live in neighbouring provinces of China, especially Sichuan, Qinghai and Gansu - which have all seen robust protests in the past few days.

China's Communist Party has developed over the past 30 years of "opening and reform" a strategy of national enmeshment and economic development widely applauded inside the country and outside. Many millions have seized the opportunity to claw their way out of poverty.

But this has failed to gain the same traction among some of the Tibetans, who feel the best opportunities in the region are going to the Han Chinese - even if the reality is more likely that the Han are culturally more ready and receptive to get on board the train to prosperity.

At the same time, the Government has expected the Tibetans to subdue their other cultural priorities - as it has expected all Chinese to focus on economic development.

This has proved counter-productive, given the extent to which the identity of the Tibetans is inseparable from their Buddhist religion. About 75 of the 100 Tibetans imprisoned are Buddhist monks or nuns.

Top

China hit by a dozen earthquakes

From correspondents in Beijing, The Australian
March 22, 2008

AT least a dozen earthquakes hit China's remote northwestern region of Xinjiang on Friday, flattening or damaging more than 2,000 houses, but no casualties had been reported so far, Xinhua news agency said.

It said 44,000 people had been "affected" by the quakes, but gave no details.

"About 2,200 houses were damaged or flattened ... during the quakes, which also toppled hundreds of livestock sheds and vegetable greenhouses," a spokesman with the regional Department of Civil Affairs was quoted as saying.

 

Home Books Photo Gallery About David Survey Results Useful Links Submit Feedback